Skip to content

Sky: PSM Saw Over $2B Single-Day Outflow but Kept 1:1 Redemptions; Block Analitica Says CoinDesk Report Misleading

Nov 20, 23:25

November 20 — Sky Protocol (formerly MakerDAO) posted a statement on X responding to yesterday's negative CoinDesk report on its Peg Stability Module (PSM). Sky disclosed that on November 19, users redeemed more than $2 billion of USDS for USDC 1:1 through the PSM, one of the largest single-day outflows the module has seen to date. Throughout the period, the PSM maintained normal 1:1 redemptions, its USDC reserves never fell below $800 million and have since recovered above $1.1 billion, and the protocol's total collateral (about $9.3 billion) remains above the combined circulating supply of USDS and DAI.

In addition, a review by DeFi risk analysis firm Block Analitica of the CoinDesk report found that several of its core allegations are misleading or taken out of context:

  1. The $518 million in so-called "illicit funds" cited in the report spans five years and accounts for less than 0.06% of the PSM's cumulative total volume of more than $960 billion; about two-thirds of it occurred during the old MakerDAO PSM era from 2021 to mid-2024, and its share in the current LitePSM is under 0.03%.
  2. The claim of "swapping freezable USDC for a censorship-resistant stablecoin" does not match the facts: of the $91.5 million linked to the Bybit hack, only about $560,000 involved wallets swapping USDC they held into DAI. The vast majority of the rest was generated when the hackers sold ETH and third-party aggregators such as 1inch, ParaSwap and MetaMask Swaps automatically routed trades through the PSM in pursuit of the best quotes; these were not initiated through the official Sky or Spark frontends.
  3. The report says $101.9 million is "directly linked" to North Korean hackers, but the actual tracing paths are mostly separated by two or more hops, and the so-called "sanctioned entities" were largely early transactions completed before those addresses were formally added to sanctions lists.

Sky also published its latest financial data, saying that the PSM and Sky Agents together hold $2.3 billion in stablecoins, that the protocol's total revenue over the past 12 months reached $412 million (up 7.8% year on year) with net income of $131 million (up 48.5% year on year), and that its risk reserve stands at $93.2 million.