Crypto and Stocks Both Sold Off — Is There More Downside? A Deep Debrief with Three Veteran Traders
Topic: After the crypto-stock double selloff: hold, buy the dip, or wait?
- Host: Amelia, SmartX
- Guests: David, founder / CEO of SmartX; 链研社, data-driven trader; 老白, previously investment research at ABCDE and OKX Ventures, now Amber Group Advisor
Both crypto and stocks have been weak over the past two weeks; US equities have posted consecutive losing sessions, with Nvidia down more than 10% last week; bitcoin broke below 70,000 a few days ago, having been consolidating around 65,000 at the time. The market is broadly split between two camps: buy the dip, or wait and see.
What Is Actually Falling in This Selloff
David
- Bitcoin went from about 75,000 to the 60,000s very quickly — it is not simply a matter of liquidating longs; it fell from about 78,000 to about 62,000 / 61,900 in under a week.
- He believes the core issue is not that bitcoin or crypto fundamentals broke, but that after AI stocks fell, traditional financial institutions needed to top up equity positions and margin, so they sold the most liquid assets in tandem.
- The deeper logic: inflation, and market expectations that rates could rise next month, or even at the next two to three FOMC meetings — the market is fairly pessimistic about future liquidity.
- There is no single "who you should listen to": different trading preferences and position sizes need to be matched with different views. This is also why they are working on personalization. He said SmartX's next step is to match markets and traders to users' preferences and styles.
链研社
- Funding conditions have been bearish lately. Macro data hasn't really met expectations, and after the market's turn it began pricing a December rate hike, even expecting further hikes in January and March next year — a tight environment; high-beta assets like bitcoin come under pressure first.
- The real weakening came after the CPI release. The transcript mentions a violent drop of about 28% from a high of 87,000 — a magnitude rarely seen in bitcoin's history.
- Applying the previous cycle as a template, after reclaiming the MA120 the maximum drawdown should have bottomed at the MA120, around 75,000. Many veterans added positions there, but it didn't stop falling, and the decline exceeded expectations. He sees the second half of the move as bitcoin catching down to macro and US equities.
- AI supply chain: he mentioned that after the Democrats took down Nvidia, the sector's leader, some tech valuations are now lower than those of some consumer stocks, which he sees as extreme.
- On-chain: shorts are still fairly concentrated; Nvidia short positions haven't been closed down much either. As for smart money, before the drop you could see overall short open interest increasing, with short positions exceeding longs.
- Bottom signals (still being validated): the first bottom of this cycle was 57,000; the second bottom he is watching is 62,000. He focuses on funding rates and on open interest needing to decline (longs capitulating, a healthier market); the Coinbase premium is returning to normal. The less good news: stablecoins are still seeing outflows, bitcoin ETFs are still seeing outflows, pressure remains, but the market is slowly grinding out a bottom.
- Crypto strengthened last night: the Nasdaq fell about 2% yesterday while bitcoin spiked to 65,000 intraday and then held steadily at 64,000. As long as 64,000 holds, he doesn't look lower; 62,000 should be a medium-term bottom.
- He agrees with David's liquidity explanation: bitcoin has the best liquidity, so institutions topping up margin sell it first; over the weekend before the US market opened, assets with off-hours trading such as gold and bitcoin also fell.
老白
- Native crypto users really like high volatility plus high liquidity; in the past they didn't look much at revenue and fundamentals, and focused more on narrative. This cycle the water has largely been used up, and the supply side has too much (too many altcoins), so it is hard to make any single asset both highly volatile and deep enough — many altcoins just grind lower after listing on mainstream exchanges.
- After Hyperliquid appeared, people found they could support volatility in a way closer to US stocks, grounded in fundamentals rather than stories alone; he thinks Hyperliquid has done very well on fundamentals, capital and liquidity.
- US stocks becoming "crypto-fied" and tokenized US equities have given crypto users instruments that offer both volatility and better fundamentals. He cites Micron, Intel and SanDisk, which can halve or double within one to two weeks — volatility no less than crypto's.
- On calling bull and bear markets: he admits he isn't accurate at it, and hasn't reached financial freedom because of it. Of the dozens of indicators summarized last cycle, about 90% stop working in the next one. Among the gurus he respects — mysticism, K-lines, fundamentals — no one saw 62,000 this round. What changes relatively little is bitcoin's four-year cycle, which can only serve as a rough reference for tops and bottoms.
Picking Sides: A Shakeout, or More Downside
The host asked each of the three to take a clear side.
David: Both — the big cycle is still there, but this is still a bear market.
- After April 11 last year, price fell from the high into July–August this year, then rebounded. He was already somewhat skeptical of the late-July rally: his futures position around 65,000 was roughly $2 million, and he closed basically all of it when price rose to 72,000. He recalls it was news announced by Trump (he says possibly the GENIUS Act or something similar), and the market pulled up nearly 8%–9% in about 15 minutes intraday.
- It took only seven or eight months to fall from 120,000 to the 60,000s, and then it was treated as a bear-to-bull turn, which he thinks was too fast. In hindsight, the July move from the 60,000s to the 80,000s was just short-term news, not a bear-to-bull turn. The 83,000–84,000 area cleared out a wave of longs; this looks more like a healthy retracement, and the cycle timeline has not yet reached a bear-to-bull turn.
- If the next month or so brings consolidation in the 60,000s followed by a move up, that would look more like a cycle rotation. His book has drawn down heavily recently, and in his own review he says he got that call wrong.
链研社: 62,000 is the second bottom, still being validated; for now he doesn't see a new low.
- By year-end, the probability that price chops around without breaking 62,000 is growing, but it is not yet validated. If bitcoin holds 64,000–62,000, he won't look for a new low.
- Time window: it should become clear within the next month at the latest. If 62,000 isn't broken in that month, the cycle that started at 57,000 is basically confirmed, and a new low is unlikely afterwards.
- Macro expectations are priced too fully: the market has priced in five rate hikes, which is a bit absurd; the macro backdrop doesn't support hikes of that size — employment and the consumer side would crack first; some relatively positive information can't get released right now because the market is already too pessimistic.
- Personal mistake: he didn't stop out decisively when the bull/bear trendline broke, believing too firmly that the bull market had already started. He draws an analogy with the big drawdown in March 2020: around the halving, when bitcoin got above 10,000, many people added leverage — similar to this time above 80,000, looking at 100,000. Even without the hack, there would have been a big drawdown; this time leverage, macro, the Nvidia scandal and Binance-related events resonated, carving out a second bottom at 62,000 with a magnitude that exceeded everyone's expectations.
- For now he treats 62,000 as this cycle's second bottom and will keep tracking data. He is relatively bullish on the road ahead: price and US equity valuations/earnings have reached a fairly reasonable level. The Google transcription reads "has already broken below Buffett's cost." Nvidia's long-term negatives haven't fully played out; he doesn't think Nvidia has bottomed, but quite a few quality assets are already showing signs of a bottom. The hardware index hasn't necessarily bottomed — there may be a chance to trim next year; investment banks expect capex to drop about 20%, and after this valuation compression it could be a better place to act. He also mentions a long-term reference: US stocks mostly rise after midterm elections — buying the index, the historical pattern of equities trending up over the long run, has not been broken.
老白: On the four-year cycle, around 60,000 is likely the bottom range; express your position through probability, don't go all in at once.
- Close to David: the one indicator that hasn't failed is the big four-year cycle. If you are patient and only trade bitcoin — sell at the end of 2017, buy at the end of 2018, sell at the end of 2021, buy at the end of 2022, sell at the end of 2025 — even if you don't sell the exact top (selling at 17,000–18,000 in 2017, or 100,000–110,000 in 2025 would also do), buying back a year later still captures a very large gain.
- October 2025 was around 120,000-plus, and it is now a bit more than a year later; by the pattern it should be bottoming, so around 60,000 is likely the bottom range.
- Two methods: first, roughly right beats precisely right — whether you sell the top at 69,000, 65,000 or 60,000 matters less, and whether you buy the bottom at 57,000, 60,000 or 65,000 isn't a big difference either; if you think it's a bottom range, you can pick your moment to enter. Second, use probability instead of "once I decide it's the bottom, go all in with leverage": if you think there's a 70% chance of a bottom, your position should express that probability.
If You Were Allocating Again, How Would You Position
David (assuming $1 million)
- Crypto, especially bitcoin, would be a bit over 50% of the portfolio.
- US stocks are awkward: two or three months ago he cleared out almost all of his spot US equity positions (keeping some he considers not closely tied to AI), and now he only trades two- to three-week swings or trends rather than holding for a year. Two or three months ago he already thought AI stocks would fall, but the drop exceeded his expectation at the time (he had thought maybe to the 180–190 area). If he allocated to US stocks now, it would be about 10%–20%, leaning toward biotech/pharma or consumer names; he notes Apple barely moved in this selloff.
- About 30% in cash, waiting to see the next step.
- On US stocks he is half optimistic, half pessimistic; on bitcoin about 80% optimistic, 20% pessimistic. There's no need to fight for the perfect entry point — in the end there's no essential difference between 3 million and 3.5 million.
链研社
- Crypto itself is a cyclical industry, and now it offers a chance to re-allocate; if it went straight up from 80,000, many people would be left on the sidelines. If the cycle is confirmed by year-end, it's a very good re-entry point; be cautious with altcoins — it's hard to outperform bitcoin, and easy to pick the wrong one.
- He isn't that pessimistic on US stocks: the driver is still corporate earnings, and as long as valuations aren't a big problem, pension and other money will slowly dollar-cost-average back in. This round's valuation compression was too fast; pricking the bubble early isn't necessarily a bad thing. AI's cash flow and the industry/products themselves are fine, and we're now roughly in the middle stage where cash flow becomes visible; what the market worries about is debt — whether the longer-dated money can be repaid. With hardware falling, compute costs decline, which is actually good for the profits and financials of AI software companies.
- As long as a company's fundamentals are fine and it is still making money, the share price will rise over the long run; there's no need to bet too heavily on presidential transitions, government rotation or macro. He doesn't think it will turn into a dot-com-bubble situation where narrative exceeds cash flow and prices then drop 90%, because cash flow has now been verified and there is a floor. Most AI compute stocks have already more than halved from their highs; if cash flow is fine and the debt can be rolled over, you can buy a little, while keeping track of earnings and fundamentals.
老白
- Over the next year or so, US stocks won't be his focus. Aside from Circle in his pension account, his personal spot holdings are Intel and Novo Nordisk.
- US stocks overall are still relatively high on a long-cycle view, and he still won't touch hardware names such as Nvidia, Micron, SanDisk or SK Hynix.
- Intel: he thinks it has been oversold rather hard and its fundamentals aren't that bad, with the current price in the 150–160 range; he is bullish on Intel competing with TSMC in the future, and thinks that from the US government's perspective, Intel and Micron are the cornerstone of guaranteeing American manufacturing — a bit like Huawei in China — so in the medium to long term it shouldn't stay at this price. He holds spot and isn't too afraid of drawdowns.
- Novo Nordisk: mainly because it has fallen so much. Eli Lilly has already crossed $1 trillion and tirzepatide is very hot, but he doesn't think semaglutide is more than ten times worse; the dividend yield is already high, it is well off its high and is stabilizing a little at the bottom, so he bought a small position.
- SpaceX: he might consider it if it fell below 100; right now he thinks it's a good thing but not cheap.
- Altcoins: some of his are still underwater. He has long wanted to buy Hyperliquid but hasn't found a good price; if it grinds at the bottom and comes to around 50–60 he might step in. He currently holds Zcash, NEAR and ENA, which map to narratives the West favors this cycle: ENA for DeFi and USD1, NEAR for intents, Zcash for privacy. He admits he bought the dip too early in NEAR and ENA.
- Circle: short term he still sees downside (the terms with Coinbase, revenue and P/E haven't reached "good asset + low valuation" yet), but this is pension money he can't touch for 20 years, so he has patience. He compares Circle / stablecoins to bitcoin in 2015–2016 or Ethereum in 2017: it is already hot inside the circle, while most of his friends outside haven't used it and don't understand it; it may take another 5–10 years before it enters the payments of daily consumption and the agent economy. He is looking at expansion ten years out, and 30–60 is all within the range where he would buy.
- Bitcoin probability portfolio (example: $1 million, believing there is a 70% chance the bottom is around 60,000 and a 30% chance it could go to 50,000 or even 40,000): use 40%–50% to buy spot in three or four tranches around 60,000 and hold; sell put options with a 50,000 strike 3–6 months out with part of it (he mentions this is how Duan Yongping bought the bottom in Apple) — if it doesn't fall to 50,000 he can collect about 5%–10% in premium, and if it does, that amounts to taking delivery at 50,000; then use about 5%–10% to buy longer-dated leap calls (for example end-2027 or mid-2028, strike around 80,000), betting that in one to two years it could reach 100,000 or the prior high of 120,000; and keep 10%–15% in cash, untouched unless there's an extreme move. Midway he verbally corrected the "sell call / sell put" wording; the above follows his final summary: roughly half in spot, 10%–15% cash, about 30%–35% selling puts, and 5%–10% in long-dated calls, to express the call that it's 70% likely bottomed.
Conclusions and Disagreements
- None of the three advocates panic-selling here, and none advocates going all-in once they judge it the absolute bottom.
- On the 60,000 area being a bottom range, 链研社 and 老白 are more explicit (62,000 / around 60,000); David stresses more that the market is still in a bear market, and that it needs more than a month of consolidation in the 60,000s followed by a move up before it looks more like a cycle reversal.
- 链研社 works more from data: funding rates, open interest, premium, stablecoin and ETF outflows, and the levels 64,000 / 62,000 / 57,000.
- 老白 reduces his method to "roughly right + expressing probability through options and position size."
- On US stocks, David has sharply cut exposure and prefers short timeframes; 链研社 thinks that after valuation compression he is actually less pessimistic, and software and cash-flow-positive companies are worth watching; 老白 hasn't made US stocks a focus for the past year or so, holding only Intel and Novo Nordisk — which he sees as wrongly sold off or fully fallen — plus Circle in his pension.
- Points of uncertainty in the transcript: which exact asset had the 23% drop on November 4; the ETF outflow "several billion" is only a verbal approximation; the "five hikes" is a paraphrase of what the market has priced; the line about Google and Buffett; and the Early Owl prize pool amount.
Join the official Coincamps community:
Telegram: https://t.me/coin_camps
Recommended
Cardano Ecosystem Stablecoin DJED Announces Shutdown: After Nearly Four Years of Operation, Holders Must Complete Redemption Before New Year's Day
Nov 18, 14:45
From Crypto Venture Capital to Traditional Venture Capital: The Three Core Competencies That Venture Capital Actually Needs
Nov 18, 14:41
Nvidia Earnings Call: Board Rules Out Huang Return, Guides Q4 to $130B
Nov 18, 14:31
The AI bubble has already burst, yet retail investors are still frantically buying the dip: Hedge fund veteran warns Nvidia risks are far from cleared
Nov 18, 14:31
Research Report Analysis | Space Fund Size Grows to $18 Billion in One Year, but On-Orbit Direct Investment Accounts for Only 3%
Nov 18, 14:18
World Bank Partners with Citi and Circle: Global Aid Funds Expected to Be Settled On-Chain via USDC
Nov 18, 14:15